1
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://we.phorge.it/source/phorge.git synced 2024-12-01 19:22:42 +01:00

Remove "Large Changes" documentation and make some minor behavioral improvements

Summary:
Depends on D19296. Ref T13110.

  - Remove the "Large Changesets" documentation since we now degrade very large changesets and I don't have any evidence that anyone has ever tried to follow any of the recommendations in this document.
  - Remove references to it.
  - When an older revision doesn't have denormalized size information on the Revision object itself, don't render a scale element (instead of rendering a bogus one).
  - Try to improve terminology consistency around "Large Change" (100-1000 files) vs "Very Large Change" (1000+ files) vs "Enormous Change" (too large to hold in memory).

Test Plan: Viewed revisions; grepped for documentation.

Maniphest Tasks: T13110

Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D19298
This commit is contained in:
epriestley 2018-04-05 05:26:18 -07:00
parent 1b363a831e
commit f01c2e3694
7 changed files with 16 additions and 65 deletions

View file

@ -56,10 +56,7 @@ final class DifferentialCreateRawDiffConduitAPIMethod
throw new Exception( throw new Exception(
pht( pht(
'The raw diff you have submitted is too large to parse (it affects '. 'The raw diff you have submitted is too large to parse (it affects '.
'more than %s paths and hunks). Differential should only be used '. 'more than %s paths and hunks).',
'for changes which are small enough to receive detailed human '.
'review. See "Differential User Guide: Large Changes" in the '.
'documentation for more information.',
new PhutilNumber($raw_limit))); new PhutilNumber($raw_limit)));
} }

View file

@ -158,7 +158,7 @@ final class DifferentialRevisionViewController extends DifferentialController {
if (count($changesets) > $limit && !$large) { if (count($changesets) > $limit && !$large) {
$count = count($changesets); $count = count($changesets);
$warning = new PHUIInfoView(); $warning = new PHUIInfoView();
$warning->setTitle(pht('Very Large Diff')); $warning->setTitle(pht('Large Diff'));
$warning->setSeverity(PHUIInfoView::SEVERITY_WARNING); $warning->setSeverity(PHUIInfoView::SEVERITY_WARNING);
$warning->appendChild(hsprintf( $warning->appendChild(hsprintf(
'%s <strong>%s</strong>', '%s <strong>%s</strong>',

View file

@ -742,6 +742,12 @@ final class DifferentialRevision extends DifferentialDAO
return $this->getProperty(self::PROPERTY_LINES_REMOVED); return $this->getProperty(self::PROPERTY_LINES_REMOVED);
} }
public function hasLineCounts() {
// This data was not populated on older revisions, so it may not be
// present on all revisions.
return isset($this->properties[self::PROPERTY_LINES_ADDED]);
}
public function getRevisionScaleGlyphs() { public function getRevisionScaleGlyphs() {
$add = $this->getAddedLineCount(); $add = $this->getAddedLineCount();
$rem = $this->getRemovedLineCount(); $rem = $this->getRemovedLineCount();

View file

@ -109,7 +109,10 @@ final class DifferentialRevisionListView extends AphrontView {
$item->setHeader($revision->getTitle()); $item->setHeader($revision->getTitle());
$item->setHref($revision->getURI()); $item->setHref($revision->getURI());
$item->addAttribute($this->renderRevisionSize($revision)); $size = $this->renderRevisionSize($revision);
if ($size !== null) {
$item->addAttribute($size);
}
if ($revision->getHasDraft($viewer)) { if ($revision->getHasDraft($viewer)) {
$draft = id(new PHUIIconView()) $draft = id(new PHUIIconView())
@ -193,6 +196,10 @@ final class DifferentialRevisionListView extends AphrontView {
} }
private function renderRevisionSize(DifferentialRevision $revision) { private function renderRevisionSize(DifferentialRevision $revision) {
if (!$revision->hasLineCounts()) {
return null;
}
$size = array(); $size = array();
$glyphs = $revision->getRevisionScaleGlyphs(); $glyphs = $revision->getRevisionScaleGlyphs();

View file

@ -74,9 +74,6 @@ often well-correlated with complexity.
We generally follow these practices in Phabricator. The median change size for We generally follow these practices in Phabricator. The median change size for
Phabricator is 35 lines. Phabricator is 35 lines.
See @{article:Differential User Guide: Large Changes} for information about
reviewing big checkins.
= Write Sensible Commit Messages = = Write Sensible Commit Messages =
There are lots of resources for this on the internet. All of them say pretty There are lots of resources for this on the internet. All of them say pretty

View file

@ -66,8 +66,6 @@ Continue by:
- diving into the details of inline comments in - diving into the details of inline comments in
@{article:Differential User Guide: Inline Comments}; or @{article:Differential User Guide: Inline Comments}; or
- reading the FAQ at @{article:Differential User Guide: FAQ}; or - reading the FAQ at @{article:Differential User Guide: FAQ}; or
- learning about handling large changesets in
@{article:Differential User Guide: Large Changes}; or
- learning about test plans in - learning about test plans in
@{article:Differential User Guide: Test Plans}; or @{article:Differential User Guide: Test Plans}; or
- learning more about Herald in @{article:Herald User Guide}. - learning more about Herald in @{article:Herald User Guide}.

View file

@ -1,54 +0,0 @@
@title Differential User Guide: Large Changes
@group userguide
Dealing with huge changesets, and when **not** to use Differential.
= Overview =
When you want code review for a given changeset, Differential is not always the
right tool to use. The rule of thumb is that you should only send changes to
Differential if you expect humans to review the actual differences in the source
code from the web interface. This should cover the vast majority of changes but,
for example, you usually should //not// submit changes like these through
Differential:
- Committing an entire open source project to a private repo somewhere so
you can fork it or link against it.
- Committing an enormous text datafile, like a list of every English word or a
dump of a database.
- Making a trivial (e.g., find/replace or codemod) edit to 10,000 files.
You can still try submitting these kinds of changes, but you may encounter
problems getting them to work (database or connection timeouts, for example).
Differential is pretty fast and scalable, but at some point either it or the
browser will break down: you simply can't show nine million files on a webpage.
More importantly, in all these cases, the text of the changes won't be reviewed
by a human. The metadata associated with the change is what needs review (e.g.,
what are you checking in, where are you putting it, and why? Does the change
make sense? In the case of automated transformations, what script did you use?).
To get review for these types of changes, one of these strategies will usually
work better than trying to get the entire change into Differential:
- Send an email/AIM/IRC to your reviewer(s) like "Hey, I'm going to check in
the source for MySQL 9.3.1 to /full/path/to/whatever. The change is staged
in /home/whatever/path/somewhere if you want to take a look. Can I put your
name on the review?". This is best for straightforward changes. The reviewer
is not going to review MySQL's source itself, instead they are reviewing the
change metadata: which version are you checking in, why are you checking it
in, and where are you putting it? You won't be able to use "arc commit" or
"arc amend" to actually push the change. Just use "svn" or "git" and
manually edit the commit message instead. (It is normally sufficient to add
a "Reviewed By: <username>" field.)
- Create a Differential revision with only the metadata, like the script you
used to make automated changes or a text file explaining what you're doing,
and maybe a sample of some of the changes if they were automated. Include a
link to where the changes are staged so reviewers can look at the actual
changeset if they want to. This is best for more complicated changes, since
Differential can still be used for discussion and provide a permanent record
others can refer to. Once the revision is accepted, amend your local commit
(e.g. by `git commit --amend`) with the real change and push as usual.
These kinds of changes are generally rare and don't have much in common, which
is why there's no explicit support for them in Differential. If you frequently
run into cases which Differential doesn't handle, let us know what they are.