Summary:
Ref T13513. Currently, clicking "View" from the inline comment preview (below the "add comment" area at the bottom of the page) only works if the inline isn't being edited.
Update this behavior so it works on inlines in either "Viewing" or "Editing" states.
Test Plan:
- Clicked "View" on a normal inline, got jumped/selected.
- Clicked "View" on an editing inline, got jumped/selected.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21237
Summary:
Ref T13513. Currently:
- If you click the "Show Changeset" button, your state change doesn't actually get saved on the server.
- It's hard to select a changeset path name for copy/paste because the "highlight the header" code tends to eat the event.
Instead: persist the former event; make the actual path text not be part of the highlight hitbox.
Test Plan:
- Clicked "Show Changeset", reloaded, saw changeset visibility persisted.
- Selected changeset path text without issues.
- Clicked non-text header area to select/deselect changesets.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21236
Summary:
Ref T13513. Currently, if you:
- click a line to create an inline;
- type some text;
- wait a moment; and
- close the page.
...you don't get an "Unsubmitted Draft" marker in the revision list.
Lift all the draft behavior to "InlineController" and make saving a draft dirty the overall container draft state.
Test Plan:
- Took the steps described above, got a draft state marker.
- Created, edited, submitted, etc., inlines in Diffusion and Differential.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21235
Summary: Ref T13513. All queries now go through a reasonably minimal set of pathways and should have consistent behavior.
Test Plan:
- Loaded a revision with inlines.
- Created a new empty inline, reloaded page, saw it vanish.
- Created a new empty inline, typed draft text, did not save, reloaded page, saw draft present.
- Created a new empty inline, typed draft text. Submitted feedback, got prompt, answered "Y", saw draft text submit.
- Created a new empty inline, typed draft text, scrolled down to bottom of page, typed non-draft text, saw preview include draft text.
- Marked and submitted "Done".
- Used hide/show on inlines, verified state persisted.
- Did much of the same stuff in Diffusion, where it all works the same way (except: there's no prompt when submitting draft is-editing inlines).
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21234
Summary: Ref T13513. Replaces "DifferentialInlineCommentQuery" with the similar but more modern "DifferentialDiffInlineCommentQuery".
Test Plan: Viewed comments in timeline, changesets. Created, edited, and submitted comments. Hid and un-hid comments, reloading (saw state preserved).
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21233
Summary: Ref T13513. Continue removing usage sites for the obsolete "DifferentialInlineCommentQuery".
Test Plan: Viewed the inline list in Differential, saw sensible inlines.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21232
Summary: Ref T13513. Move querying to "DiffInlineCommentQuery" classes and lift them into the base Controller.
Test Plan: In Differential and Diffusion, created, edited, and submitted inline comments.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21231
Summary: Ref T13513. Another step closer to the light.
Test Plan: Created, edited, deleted, replied to, and submitted inline comments in Diffusion.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21230
Summary: Ref T13513. Continue marching toward coherent query pathways for all access to inline comments.
Test Plan:
- Viewed a commit and a path within that commit, as a user with unpublished inlines and a different user.
- Saw appropriate inlines in all cases (published inlines, plus undeleted unpublished inlines authored by the current viewer).
- Grepped for "loadDraftAndPublishedComments()".
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21228
Summary:
Ref T13513. Improve consistency and robustness of the "InlineComment" queries.
The only real change here is that these queries now implicitly add a clause for selecting inlines ("pathID IS NULL" or "changesetID IS NULL").
Test Plan: Browed, created, edited, and submitted inlines.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21227
Summary:
Ref T13513. Currently, inline storage objects ("TransactionComment") can't directly generate a runtime object ("InlineComment").
Allow this transformation to be performed in a genric way so clunky code which does it per-object-type can be removed, lifted, or simplified.
Simplify an especially gross callsite in preview code.
Test Plan: Previewed inline comments.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21226
Summary: Ref T13513. See that task for some discussion. This prepares to lift "loadUnsubmittedInlineComments(...)" into shared code.
Test Plan: Grepped for callers, found none in the upstream. This is a backward compatibilty break. See T13513.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21225
Summary: Ref T13513. This controller was obsoleted by EditEngine and appears unreachable without explicitly typing the URL.
Test Plan:
- Grepped for the route, didn't find any hits.
- Deleted the controller, successfully previewed comments in Diffusion.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21224
Summary:
Ref T13519. This is a little fuzzy, but I think the workflow here is:
- View an intradiff, generating an ephemeral comparison changeset with no changeset ID. This produces a state key of "*".
- Apply "hidden" state changes to the changeset.
- View some other intradiff and/or diff view.
- The code attempts to use "*" as a changset ID?
I'm not entirely sure this is accurate; this was observed in production and I couldn't get a clean reproduction case locally.
Optimistically, try making changeset IDs explicit rather than relying on state keys to be "usually changeset-ID-like".
Test Plan: Used "hidden" locally across multiple intradiffs, but I wasn't cleanly able to reproduce the initial issue.
Maniphest Tasks: T13519
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21223
Summary: See D21213. If there's no matching element, `findAbove()` throws. Handle these cases correctly.
Test Plan: Visited `#toc` on a revision, no longer saw a JS error.
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21222
Summary: Ref T13523. If a file hasn't been touched in the newer changeset, we can currently hit an error in the interdiff.
Test Plan:
- Touched "moo.txt" in Diff 1.
- Reverted the changes to "moo.txt" in Diff 2.
- Diffed 2 vs 1.
- Before patch: fatal (call to getFilename() on null).
- After patch: clean interdiff.
Maniphest Tasks: T13523
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21220
Summary:
Ref T13513. Overloading "original text" to get "edit-on-load" comments into the right state has some undesirable side effects.
Instead, provide the text when the editor opens. This fixes a cancel interaction.
Test Plan:
- Create an inline, type text, don't save.
- Reload page.
- Cancel.
- Before: cancelled into empty state.
- After: cancelled into deleted+undo state.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21219
Summary: Ref T13513. When users choose to publish inlines, we want to publish the visible text, not the last "checkpointed" state.
Test Plan:
- Created an inline ("AAA").
- Edited it into "BBB", did not save.
- Submitted.
- Confirmed that I want to publish the unsaved inline.
- Saw "BBB" publish.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21218
Summary:
Ref T13513. This is a bit clumsy, but the cleanest way to implement "isEditing" inlines today is to send them down as normal inlines and then simulate clicking "edit" on them.
When we do, don't focus the resulting editor: focusing it makes the page scroll around and highlight things in essentially random order as the editors load in.
Test Plan: Reloaded a page with some open editors, wasn't scrolled to them.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21217
Summary:
Ref T13513. As users type text into inline comments, save the comment state as a draft on the server.
This has some rough edges, particularly around previews, but mostly works. See T13513 for notes.
Test Plan: Started an inline, typed some text, waited a second, reloaded the page, saw an editing inline with the saved text.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21216
Summary: Ref T13513. When computing whether a revision has draft comments or not, ignore empty inlines.
Test Plan: Added empty inlines to a revision, no longer saw a yellow "draft" bubble in the list UI.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21215
Summary: Ref T13513. When you load a changeset, discard all empty inlines. This is likely a more desirable behavior than keeping empty editors around, even though the rest of the pipeline generally handles them fairly well now.
Test Plan:
- Started an inline, didn't type any text or save, reloaded page.
- Before: page restores empty editor in the same place.
- After: we just discard this likely-pointless empty inline.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21214
Summary: Ref T13513. Refine some inline behaviors, see test plan.
Test Plan:
- Edit a comment ("A"), type text ("AB"), cancel, edit.
- Old behavior: edit and undo states (wrong, and undo does not function).
- New behavior: edit state only.
- Edit a comment ("A"), type text ("AB"), cancel. Undo ("AB"), cancel. Edit.
- Old behavior: "AB" (wrong: you never submitted this text).
- New behavior: "A".
- Create a comment, type text, cancel.
- Old behavior: counter appears in filetree (wrong, comment is undo-able but should not be counted).
- New behavior: no counter.
- Cancel editing an empty comment with no text.
- Old behavior: Something buggy -- undo, I think?
- New behavior: it just vanishes (correct behavior).
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21212
Summary:
Ref T13513. Currently, if you start an inline and then submit overall comments, we publish an empty inline. This is literally faithful to what you did, but almost certainly not the intent.
Instead, simply ignore empty inlines at publishing time (and ignore "done" state changes for those comments).
We could delete them outright, but if we do, they'll break if you have another window open with the empty inline (since the stored comment won't exist anymore). At least for now, leave them in place.
Test Plan: Created empty inlines, submitted comments, no longer saw them publish.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21211
Summary: Ref T13513. This slightly expands the existing-but-hacky "warning" workflow to cover both "mentions on draft" and "submitting inlines being edited".
Test Plan:
- Submitted changes to a revision with mentions on a draft, inlines being edited, both, and neither.
- Got sensible warnings in the cases where warnings were appropriate.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21191
Summary:
Ref T13513. If you submit top-level comments while an inline comment editor is open, kick the comment out of the editing state.
(An improvement to this behavior would be to warn the user that we're going to do this first, but this is currently less straightforward.)
Test Plan:
- Clicked a line number to create an inline.
- Type text, save, click edit.
- (Optional: reload page.)
- Save changes overall using the form at the bottom of the page.
- Outcome: published inline is no longer in an "editing" state.
Weirdness:
- If you click a line number (and, optionally, type text), then submit without using "Save", the server-side version of the inline has no content.
- This gives you a no-effect warning. Instead, these inlines should probably just be marked as deleted somewhere in the pipeline.
- This saves the last "Saved" copy of the inline. That's (probably?) desired, but somewhat destructive without a warning.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21188
Summary:
Ref T13513. Now that the "currently being edited" state of inlines is saved on the server side, clear the flag when the user clicks "Cancel" to leave the "editing" state on the client.
This also serves to delete empty comments.
Test Plan:
- Clicked a line number to create a new comment. Then:
- Clicked "Cancel". Reloaded page, saw no more comment.
- Typed text, saved. Reloaded page, saw non-editing draft. Clicked "Edit", reloaded page, saw editing draft. Clicked "Cancel", reloaded page, saw non-editing draft.
- Typed text, saved. Clicked "Edit", deleted text, saved. Reloaded page, saw no more comment.
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21187
Summary:
Ref T13513. This is mostly an infrastructure cleanup change.
In a perfect world, this would be a series of several changes, but they're tightly interconnected and don't have an obvious clean, nontrivial partition (or, at least, I don't see one). Followup changes will exercise this code repeatedly and all of these individual mutations are "obviously good", so I'm not too worried about the breadth of this change.
---
Inline comments are stored as transaction comments in the `PhabricatorAuditTransactionComment` and `DifferentialTransactionComment` classes.
On top of these two storage classes sit `PhabricatorAuditInlineComment` and `DifferentialInlineComment`. Historically, these were an indirection layer over significantly different storage classes, but nowadays both storage classes look pretty similar and most of the logic is actually the same. Prior to this change, these two classes were about 80% copy/pastes of one another.
Part of the reason they're so copy/pastey is that they implement a parent `Interface`. They are the only classes which implement this interface, and the interface does not provide any correctness guarantees (the storage objects are not actually constrained by it).
To simplify this:
- Make `PhabricatorInlineCommentInterface` an abstract base class instead.
- Lift as much code out of the `Audit` and `Differential` subclasses as possible.
- Delete methods which no longer have callers, or have only trivial callers.
---
Inline comments have two `View` rendering classes, `DetailView` and `EditView`. They share very little code.
Partly, this is because `EditView` does not take an `$inline` object. Historically, it needed to be able to operate on inlines that did not have an ID yet, and even further back in history this was probably just an outgrowth of a simple `<form />`.
These classes can be significantly simplified by passing an `$inline` to the `EditView`, instead of individually setting all the properties on the `View` itself. This allows the `DetailView` and `EditView` classes to share a lot of code.
The `EditView` can not fully render its content. Move the content rendering code into the view.
---
Prior to this change, some operations need to work on inlines that don't have an inline ID yet (we assign an ID the first time you "Save" a comment). Since "editing" comments will now be saved, we can instead create a row immediately.
This means that all the inline code can always rely on having a valid ID to work with, even if that ID corresponds to an empty, draft, "isEditing" comment. This simplifies more code in `EditView` and allows the "create" and "reply" code to be merged in `PhabricatorInlineCommentController`.
---
Client-side inline events are currently handled through a mixture of `ChangesetList` listeners (good) and ad-hoc row-level listeners (less good). In particular, the "save", "cancel", and "undo" events are row-level. All other events are list-level.
Move all events to list-level. This is supported by all inlines now having an ID at all stages of their lifecycle.
This allows some of the client behavior to be simplified. It currently depends on binding complex ad-hoc dictionaries into event handlers in `_drawRows()`, but it seems like almost all of this code can be removed. In fact, no more than one row ever seems to be drawn, so this code can probably be simplified further.
---
Finally, save an "isEditing" state. When we rebuild a revision on the client, click the "edit" button if it's in this state. This is a little hacky, but simpler to get into a stable state, since the row layout of an inline depends on a "view row" followed by an "edit row".
Test Plan:
- Created comments on either side of a diff.
- Edited a comment, reloaded, saw edit stick.
- Saved comments, reloaded, saw save stick.
- Edited a comment, typed text, cancelled, "unedited" to get state back.
- Created a comment, typed text, cancelled, "unedited" to get state back.
- Deleted a comment, "undeleted" to get state back.
Weirdness / known issues:
- Drafts don't autosave yet.
- Fixed in D21187:
- When you create an empty comment then reload, you get an empty editor. This is a bit silly.
- "Cancel" does not save state, but should, once drafts autosave.
- Mostly fixed in D21188:
- "Editing" comments aren't handled specially by the overall submission flow.
- "Editing" comments submitted in that state try to edit themselves again on load, which doesn't work.
Subscribers: jmeador
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21186
Summary: Ref T13513. This plans for "currently editing", character range comments, code suggestions, document engine tracking. And absolutely nothing else.
Test Plan:
- Ran `bin/storage upgrade -f`, got a clean upgrade.
- Created and submitted some inline comments; nothing exploded.
Subscribers: PHID-OPKG-gm6ozazyms6q6i22gyam
Maniphest Tasks: T13513
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21184
Summary:
At some point, the highlighting behavior for the timeline broke. When you follow a link to a particular timeline story, the story should be highlighted.
Prior to this change, the `<a />` tag itself highlights, but there's no associated CSS and it's too deep in the tree to do anything useful.
(Since this change is fairly straightforward, I gave up digging for the root cause before finding it.)
Test Plan:
- Clicked a timeline story anchor, saw the story highlight.
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21213
Summary:
Ref T13523. In the caching layer, there's a tricky clause about filetypes that skips some body rendering behavior.
Provide file type information which at least has a better chance of representing all changes (e.g., an image file may be replaced with a text file, but this can not be represented by a single file type).
Formalize "hasSourceTextBody()", to mean the changeset parser should engage the change as source text.
Test Plan: Intradiffed text changes, saw the body render properly.
Maniphest Tasks: T13523
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21210
Summary: Fixes T13530. The block parser could match too many lines in an unterminated "%%%" literal block. Adjust the logic to stop doing this (and hopefully be a little easier to read).
Test Plan: Added a failing test, made it pass.
Maniphest Tasks: T13530
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21208
Summary:
See PHI1722, which requests transaction details about reviewer changes.
This adds them; they're structured to be similar to "projects" and "subscribers" transactions and the "reviewers" attachment on revisions.
Test Plan: {F7410675}
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21207
Summary: This supports the IntelliJ IDEA editor.
Test Plan:
- Looked at the editor settings panel, saw "idea://".
- Set my editor pattern to "idea://a?b".
- (Did not actually install IntelliJ IDEA.)
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21206
Summary: Ref T13528. Now that we're hinting users into Files, put the content first and move the detail panel under it. Move the most-useful details (author, size, dimensions) into the curtain.
Test Plan: {F7409925}
Maniphest Tasks: T13528
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21201
Summary:
Ref T13528. The original rationale here was that it's easier to find items at the bottom of the curtain than somewhere in the middle, since they're in a more clearly predictable visual location.
This might be true in some sense, but user feedback about this has fairly consistently indicated that the layout is surprising. Try the other order. See also D20967 for some discussion.
In practice, this primarily moves "Author / Assigned" above other panel elements in Maniphest.
Test Plan: Looked at tasks, aw "Author / Assigned" above "Tags / Subscribers".
Maniphest Tasks: T13528
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21200
Summary:
Ref T13528. Paste data is stored in files, but the files are always named "raw.txt".
Now that Paste provides a hint to use Files for "DocumentEngine" rendering, try to use the same name as the paste instead.
Test Plan:
- Created a paste named "staggering-insight.ipynb".
- Clicked "View as Jupyter Notebook" from Paste.
- Saw a file named "staggering-insight.ipynb", not "raw.txt".
- Created a paste with no name, saw a file named "raw-paste-data.txt" get created.
Maniphest Tasks: T13528
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21197
Summary: Ref T13528. When a file in Paste (like a Jupyter notebook) has a good/useful document engine, provide a link to Files.
Test Plan: {F7409881}
Maniphest Tasks: T13528
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21196
Summary:
See PHI1719. User agents making hard-coded requests to "/favicon.ico" currently 404. This is a mild source of log noise, and we can reasonably route this request.
Limitations:
- This only routes the "PlatformSite". Other sites (custom Phame blogs, third-party sites, Phurl redirectors) won't route here for now.
- This returns a "Location:" redirect to the correct resource rather than icon data directly. This produces the right icon with the right caching behavior, and returning icon data directly is difficult in the general case. However, it won't perform/cache as well as a direct response would.
Test Plan:
- Visted `/favicon.ico`.
- Before: 404.
- After: redirect to favicon.
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21195
Summary:
Ref T13526. Currently, if a build plan is restricted, viewers may fatal when trying to view related builds.
The old behavior allowed them to see the build even if they can not see the build plan. This is sort of incoherent, but try to stabilize things before fixing this.
Test Plan:
This is a muddy change.
- Created a build with a build plan that Alice can't see.
- As Alice, viewed the build page (restricted before, restricted after); the buildable page (fatal before, works after).
- Also viewed a revision page (works before and after, but user-reported fatal).
Subscribers: PHID-OPKG-gm6ozazyms6q6i22gyam
Maniphest Tasks: T13526
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21194
Summary:
See PHI1714. This code is incorrectly rendering the chart panel twice, sort of, and passing a non-View object to rendering.
After D21044, this fatals by raising an exception in rendering.
Test Plan: Loaded page, no more exception.
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21185
Summary:
Ref T13520. Generally, make the table of contents look and more like the paths panel:
- Show a hierarchy, with compression for single-sibling children.
- Use the same icons, instead of "M D" and "(img)" stuff.
- Use EditDistanceMatrix to do a piece-by-piece diff of paths changes.
- Show path changes within the path list.
I'm not entirely sold on this, but it was complicated to write and I've never heard the term "sunk cost fallacy". I think this is mostly a net improvement, but may need some adjustments and followup.
Test Plan: Viewed various changes in Differential and Diffusion, saw a more usable table of contents.
Maniphest Tasks: T13520
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21183
Summary:
See <https://discourse.phabricator-community.org/t/runtimeexception-during-import-of-commit/3801>. When importing commits with "Auditors:", a raw transaction new value (with an edge edit map using a "+" key) may be passed as an unmentionable PHID list.
Instead, pass an actual PHID list.
Test Plan:
- Pushed a commit with "Auditors: duck".
- Ran daemons.
- Before patch: umentionable PHID exception.
- After patch: clean commit import.
- Verified "duck" was added as an auditor.
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21181
Summary:
Ref T13523. Currently, when building a "comparison" changeset, metadata is taken from the left changeset. This is somewhat arbitrary.
This means that intradiffs of images don't work properly because the rendered changeset has only the left (usually "old") information.
Later, some of the code attempts to ignore the file data stored on the changeset and reconstruct the correct file data, which is how the result ends up not-completely-wrong.
Be more careful about building sensible-ish metadata, and then just use it directly later on. This fixes the "spooky" code referencing D955 + D6851.
There are some related issues, where "change type" and "file type" are selected arbitrarily and then used to determine whether the change has an "old/new" state or not (i.e., is the left side of the diff empty, since the change creates the file)?
In many cases, neither of the original changesets have a "change type" which will answer this question correctly. Separate this concept from "has state" from "change type", and make more of the code ask narrower questions about the specific conditions or states it cares about, rather than "change type".
Test Plan:
- Created a revision with Diff 1, Diff 2, and Diff 3. Diff 1 takes an image from "null -> A". Diff 2 takes the same image from "null -> B". Diff 3 takes the same image from "A -> B'.
- Intradiffed 1v2 and 1v3.
- Before patch:
- Left side usually missing, which is incorrect (should always be "A").
- Change properties are a mess ("null -> image/png" for MIME type, e.g.)
- Uninteresting/incorrect "unix:filemode" stuff.
- After patch;
- Left side shows state "A".
- Change properties only show size changes (which is correct).
{F7402012}
Maniphest Tasks: T13523
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21180
Summary:
Fixes T13525. Since D21044, the intermittent GC list warnings are treated more severely and can become user-visible errors.
Silence them, since this seems to be the only realistic response in most versions of APC/APCu.
Test Plan: Will deploy.
Maniphest Tasks: T13525
Differential Revision: https://secure.phabricator.com/D21179
